I realize you guys don't "roll it up", that's simply the term I was using to reference getting our reviews onto google.
There is a lot of confusion as to how review content makes it to the Places page. Joe's comments on Places pages and listings from
this article are a great read and highly recommended.
I'd love more feedback on some tactics to use DealerRater as more of a value prop!
What's the hockey equivalent to a softball over the middle, open net and a line change?

You tee'd that one up so high I'm afraid to swing at it.
I'm super-sensitive to anything that smells like a salespitch on this forum, I don't like reading them anymore than anybody else. That said, I am really proud to be a part of the DealerRater team and I'm excited to talk about what we do well. I was an enthusiastic fan before I had the opportunity to work here and I was really surprised at how many dealers stopped by the booth at DD10 just to say "thanks and keep up the good work." I'm going to assume most Refreshers are already aware of the importance of reviews and DealerRater's ability to assist with monitoring and managing reputation, if not PM me and I'll setup a demo for you. Here are some of the things I've been saying to my dealers recently. Hopefully this gets your creative juices flowing.
I've told a lot of dealers that if you are just building reviews and not leveraging them to close unsold prospects you are only scraping the surface. The point of building reviews is to leverage them. Peer Reviews are important to customers! Google will do some of that for you in the Places Page, but the sky is the limit and the more progressive stores are already finding new ways to get the most out of the RSS feeds and individual pages we supply. I have multiple dealers running radio campaigns that highlight their #1 ranking in their PMA, one dealer put a similar message on a billboard, one is using QR codes and custom URL's to drive customers to leave reviews, several have terminals on the showroom floor dedicated to the state directory for their make so their reps can walk prospects through their great reviews and competing stores not so great reviews, one is using that 32nd photoslot for a DealerRater certified tile, Kershner posted a great video on sharing individual reviews to your Fanpage, Sales reps are sharing their personal reviews on their personal Facebook pages...and then there are the Alpha type dealers out there gobbling up ad space on the site to create a further competitive advantage...
I'll end with this. The best tactic is to get your staff trained. Take advantage of those 6 weekly trainings and put everybody through. One of your people will have that lightbulb moment and start building and leveraging reviews and force the rest of your team to take notice when they are getting slayed on the sales board. The early adopter will drag the middle up and you probably don't want the guy that is afraid to ask for reviews because he thinks they will be negative.
Sorry for the long post and I hope that helps...