Carey,
You're numbers are looking really good. I would like to see a higher appointment percentage. To accomplish that you need to be more aggressive trying to make contact with customers. Multiple phone calls over the first few days on all Internet leads, plus effective e-mail templates that help initiate a phone conversation.
I would like to see a spread sheet that breaks out the lead type and lead source in addition to all the other information mentioned. This way it can be sorted to determine the effectiveness of advertising sources.
You're off to a great start and there's still a lot to learn. I sent your boss an e-mail and suggested that he send you to Digital Dealer.
By the way, your show rate is really awesome. I can tell you that your ability to set SOLID appointments is what's helping you achieve such a high show rate. And you do care about the sold rate since it's the true measuring stick for the effectiveness of your department. If you're team is not closing at close to 50% it becomes a sales process issue. In your case, they are looking good at 47%. The other 53%, you should do a follow-up CSI call to see what it will take to bring them back in. Here's that script:
Unsold CSI
Keep up the good work, you've been a great student!