• This thread is just the tip of the iceberg.The people ahead of the curve aren't Googling for answers — they're already in here, having the conversations you haven't found yet. DealerRefresh is free.Get the full picture →

Are you guys thinking about retention strategy for digital?

AI Summary

Dealers are spending heavily on performance marketing to drive traffic but failing to retain those visitors, essentially "renting traffic" rather than building lasting audiences. The thread identifies email follow-ups (service reminders, vehicle tips, non-salesy content) and smart retargeting ads (showing previously viewed vehicles with incentives) as effective retention tactics that keep brands top-of-mind without aggressive sales pitches. The core insight is that retention strategy is just as critical as acquisition—continuous engagement after the initial click generates higher ROI than assuming one-time visitors will remember you.

CarsonWhite

Lot Lizard
Nov 21, 2025
8
2
Awards
3
First Name
Carson
No mystery Dealer's are spending tens of thousands on performance marketing.

CDG put out an awesome post on that spend only increasing over time. Beating your competitor on ad spend is essentially an inverted race to the bottom.

Is anyone thinking about how they are retaining the traffic they pay for? What works? What doesn't?
 
Most dealers are terrible at retention. They'll spend 10k on ads to drive traffic then let those people leave after one visit and never come back. It's crazy.

What works for us is email follow-ups that aren't just "come back and buy." Service reminders, vehicle tips, local events. Stuff that keeps the brand in their inbox without screaming for a sale.

Also retargeting ads that don't suck. Show them the exact car they looked at with a small price drop or a "still interested?" message. Low effort, high return.

What doesn't work is assuming they'll remember you. They won't. You have to stay in their face after the click. Otherwise you're just renting traffic instead of building an audience.
 
Most dealers are terrible at retention. They'll spend 10k on ads to drive traffic then let those people leave after one visit and never come back. It's crazy.

What works for us is email follow-ups that aren't just "come back and buy." Service reminders, vehicle tips, local events. Stuff that keeps the brand in their inbox without screaming for a sale.

Also retargeting ads that don't suck. Show them the exact car they looked at with a small price drop or a "still interested?" message. Low effort, high return.

What doesn't work is assuming they'll remember you. They won't. You have to stay in their face after the click. Otherwise you're just renting traffic instead of building an audience.
Couldn't be more aligned
 

✨ AI Highlights

Dealers are spending heavily on performance marketing to drive traffic but failing to retain those visitors, essentially "renting traffic" rather than building lasting audiences. The thread identifies email follow-ups (service reminders, vehicle tips, non-salesy content) and smart retargeting ads (showing previously viewed vehicles with incentives) as effective retention tactics that keep brands top-of-mind without aggressive sales pitches. The core insight is that retention strategy is just as critical as acquisition—continuous engagement after the initial click generates higher ROI than assuming one-time visitors will remember you.

Replies Views 2 304 Started Last Reply