An Open Letter to Mark O'Neil - Chairman and CEO of DealerTrack
Mornin' Alex! You write: "...organic SEO is dying to TV branding?"
In this sentence what I want to say is: "Organic SEO is dying and Traditional Media is it's benefactor". Let me break it down.
Organic SEO is dying.
We all know that searchers click the top listings on the Search Return Pages (SERPs) and we know that Google is constantly adding new SERP products that push the organic results lower and lower. Over time we've seen Google Adwords (paid ads), Google Places(Local Maps) push Organic SEO lower, Now "Google Products" is yet another item that pushes the organic results lower on the page.
Google Adwords is a long tail and a short tail product. Google Local is a short tail product, and now "Google Products" is aimed at longer tail organic SERPs (e.g. year, make, model) A future "Google Products" example would be "2010 Kia Soul for sale" In almost all cases that I've seen, Google hard wires the "Google Products" result to the top of the SERP.
Ok, so how does TV win more revenue as google expands it's SERP products?
Any Automotive business that LIVES on the internet (AutoTrader.com, Cars.com, UsedCars.com, CarGurus.com, etc.) gets traffic from an assortment of sources. Internet Traffic a site can come from TV, Print, Google Paid ads and folks Google'ing the site's name. On top of all that, a portion of a sites traffic is from Organic SEO (Long Tail SERP example: "best price on 2010 Buick Enclave"). As Organic SEO real estate shrinks, so does that Organic SEO traffic.
This will produce a measurable LOSS in business. Traditional Media WINS more share because the loss in Organic SEO traffic needs to be offset.
AutoTrader and Cars business model is fueled by big investments in traditional media, UsedCars and CarGurus is not. Should "Google Products" come to our space, the lower tier players like UsedCars and CarGurus who live (or die) on Organic SEO traffic, will have the most difficult challenges to their business model.
The ridiculously brilliant Chris Dixon* wrote an article that loosely connects to what I am referring to: "SEO is no longer a viable marketing strategy for startups". SEO is no longer a viable marketing strategy for startups
** Chris Dixon: Personal investor in early-stage technology companies, including Skype, Foursquare, Kickstarter, Stack Overflow, TrialPay, DocVerse (acq by GOOG), Invite Media (acq by GOOG), Gerson Lehrman Group, ScanScout, OMGPOP, BillShrink, Panjiva, Knewton, and a handful of other startups that are still in stealth mode.
In this sentence what I want to say is: "Organic SEO is dying and Traditional Media is it's benefactor". Let me break it down.
Organic SEO is dying.
We all know that searchers click the top listings on the Search Return Pages (SERPs) and we know that Google is constantly adding new SERP products that push the organic results lower and lower. Over time we've seen Google Adwords (paid ads), Google Places(Local Maps) push Organic SEO lower, Now "Google Products" is yet another item that pushes the organic results lower on the page.
Google Adwords is a long tail and a short tail product. Google Local is a short tail product, and now "Google Products" is aimed at longer tail organic SERPs (e.g. year, make, model) A future "Google Products" example would be "2010 Kia Soul for sale" In almost all cases that I've seen, Google hard wires the "Google Products" result to the top of the SERP.
Ok, so how does TV win more revenue as google expands it's SERP products?
Any Automotive business that LIVES on the internet (AutoTrader.com, Cars.com, UsedCars.com, CarGurus.com, etc.) gets traffic from an assortment of sources. Internet Traffic a site can come from TV, Print, Google Paid ads and folks Google'ing the site's name. On top of all that, a portion of a sites traffic is from Organic SEO (Long Tail SERP example: "best price on 2010 Buick Enclave"). As Organic SEO real estate shrinks, so does that Organic SEO traffic.
This will produce a measurable LOSS in business. Traditional Media WINS more share because the loss in Organic SEO traffic needs to be offset.
AutoTrader and Cars business model is fueled by big investments in traditional media, UsedCars and CarGurus is not. Should "Google Products" come to our space, the lower tier players like UsedCars and CarGurus who live (or die) on Organic SEO traffic, will have the most difficult challenges to their business model.
The ridiculously brilliant Chris Dixon* wrote an article that loosely connects to what I am referring to: "SEO is no longer a viable marketing strategy for startups". SEO is no longer a viable marketing strategy for startups
** Chris Dixon: Personal investor in early-stage technology companies, including Skype, Foursquare, Kickstarter, Stack Overflow, TrialPay, DocVerse (acq by GOOG), Invite Media (acq by GOOG), Gerson Lehrman Group, ScanScout, OMGPOP, BillShrink, Panjiva, Knewton, and a handful of other startups that are still in stealth mode.





