Thanks! I did call an attorney just to see where I stand. He said that since I had a signed contract, and loan contract, with no mention of contingency and I had signed no paper saying I was guaranteeing that I was eligible it was very bad on the dealership's part (for them) to make the deal, and sign all paperwork. And since there is a registration fee on there he said they could not refuse to register it. He did say that to be sure he wanted to see the paperwork but that based on what he heard, in CT the car is mine if I choose to force the issue. The documents I submitted were all original and the fact that they missed what the DMV claims is the renewal date is their ultimate responsibility (because they went ahead and finalized the deal, including delivery). I do have a cancelled check showing renewal on time but, per the dealership, that does not count - only what is on the registration and what DMV says. That said, I am not trying to be a jerk about this. If I really did have a laps (still TBD) I think the right thing to do would be to work out a deal in which it is fair for all parties, as opposed to "punishing" the dealership for less than quality practices. Maybe that the $4,500 minus the blue book value of my trade and then split that with them? Justlooking to find a way we can all live with this mess.